Curbing 'faithless electors'

Curbing 'faithless electors'

  • Updated
  • 1
Only $3 for 13 weeks

It’s beyond the power of the Supreme Court to abolish the Electoral College, a hopelessly antiquated and unfair way to choose the president. But in a unanimous ruling Monday, the court at least prevented the system from becoming even less democratic.

111cc彩票下载安卓Acting on cases from Washington and Colorado, the justices held that states may punish — and even remove — electors who don’t support the presidential candidate who finished first in the popular vote there.

111cc彩票下载安卓In Colorado, which Hillary Clinton carried in 2016, an elector was replaced when he said he intended to vote for Gov. John Kasich (R-Ohio) instead. In Washington, where Clinton also won the popular vote, three electors were fined for voting for former Secretary of State Colin Powell despite having pledged to support Clinton.

111cc彩票下载安卓Writing for the court, Justice Elena Kagan said that “nothing in the Constitution expressly prohibits states from taking away presidential electors’ voting discretion.” Equally important, she noted the long practice of choosing electors based on the state’s popular vote, rather than having state lawmakers pick them.

The framers of the Constitution, she conceded, left for the future the question of “how independent from — or how faithful to — party and popular preferences the electors’ votes should be.” But, she added: “The future did not take long in coming. Almost immediately, presidential electors became trusty transmitters of other people’s decisions.”

Today 48 states award all of their electoral votes to the winner of the statewide popular vote. (Maine and Nebraska award two electors to the winner of the statewide vote and one to the winner of each congressional district.) Many voters likely don’t realize that they are actually choosing electors who will gather in their states in December to cast the ballots that decide the race.

Kagan also emphasized that states have taken steps to bind electors to the voters’ will. Thirty-two states impose such obligations, and 15 of those states impose some sort of sanction on faithless electors, with most of them providing for the replacement of renegade electors.

Monday’s decision does justice to the long historical practice of choosing electors through popular elections. But it also is true to the framers’ overriding purpose: to entrust the selection of electors to the states, which have decided to honor the voters’ wishes. To further deter faithless electors, states that don’t have laws calling for defiant electors to be replaced — California among them —111cc彩票下载安卓 should enact them.

The timing of the decision is also important. It comes in a presidential election year already clouded by the possibility of an inconclusive or contested outcome that the unprincipled incumbent might try to exploit. The court has minimized the possibility of at least one sort of disruption.

Still, welcome as Monday’s ruling is, it doesn’t alter the fact that the Electoral College is intrinsically prone to undemocratic outcomes. Two of the last three presidents — George W. Bush and Donald Trump — secured an Electoral College majority without prevailing in the popular vote. Such a discrepancy between the popular and electoral result remains a danger even if electors faithfully reflect the outcome of a state’s popular vote. That is unacceptable.

As the court noted, state election laws evolved to reinforce the notion that “a state’s electors would vote the same way as its citizens.” But the ultimate evolutionary achievement would, and must, be the abolition of the Electoral College.

111cc彩票下载安卓Los Angeles Times

Related to this story

Most Popular

While Dothan city commissioners balked at passing a mandatory mask order, even after Houston County was noted as a “very high-risk” COVID-19 a…

  • Updated

111cc彩票下载安卓As the number of COVID-19 cases began to rise in Alabama, elected officials in Dothan and Houston County failed to reach a consensus to take a…

  • Updated

On Wednesday, the morning after Alabama logged 2,141 new cases and a record 40 deaths from COVID-19 in a 24-hour period, Gov. Kay Ivey stepped…

  • Updated

111cc彩票下载安卓There’s one certainty in these uncertain times: After the polls close at 7 p.m. across Alabama, there will be Republican nominees for Congress…

  • Updated

111cc彩票下载安卓State Senate Majority Leader Del Marsh drew criticism over remarks he made to reporters over the weekend, prompting the prominent senator to r…

  • Updated

111cc彩票下载安卓Fighting COVID-19 has been hard enough, but fighting the state for a straight answer on numbers to gauge the past and current spike of new cas…

  • Updated

Tuesday is an election day in Alabama, when voters are to determine the outcome of races thrown into runoffs in the March 3 primaries.

  • Updated

The latest report on tax receipts underscores the importance of our area’s diversified economy, showing that despite a COVID 19-related shutdo…

111cc彩票下载安卓Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


Breaking News

11选5两倍多少钱 11选5旺彩计划 2020年排列五规律图下载 19年3D试机号后北京谜语汇总 2020全年3d开奖结果 158的彩的网址 168手机平台app 11选5一定牛 178众发怎么代理 0567彩的新版网站